Ontolog Forum
OntologySummit2009: Toward Ontology-based Standards
Homepage for the 2009 Ontology Summit ... This summit initiative is co-organized by NIST, Ontolog, NCOR, NCBO, OASIS, OMG, ISO TC 184/SC4, OAGi, STI International & DERI
- Read the OntologySummit2009_Communique
What's New
- 2009_10_30 - Friday: UoM_Ontology_Standard workshop (full-day, face-to-face, with remote participation support) - Co-chair: Frank Olken, Ed Barkmeyer & Howard Mason - venue: NSF (Arlington, VA, USA) - see: UoM_Ontology_Standard/Workshop_2009_10_30
- 2009_10_08 - Thursday: Progress Review on the OntologyBasedStandards sample projects identified at OntologySummit2009 - Chair: Steve Ray - Panelists: David Connelly, Matthew West, Mike Bennett, Brand Niemann, Kevin Keck, David Coggeshall, Joshua Lieberman, Ed Barkmeyer - ConferenceCall_2009_10_08
- 2009_09_24 - Thursday: UoM Panel Discussion: "Strawman for a UoM_Ontology_Standard" - Co-chair: Frank Olken & David Price - Panelists: David Leal, Chip Masters, Gunther Schadow, Ed Barkmeyer - ConferenceCall_2009_09_24
- 2009_06_19 - Friday: Ontolog Panel Discussion: "Toward a Units of Measure Ontology" - Chair: Frank Olken - Panelists: Stan Huff, David Price, DaveMcComb, Robert Dragoset, Rob Raskin, Pat Cassidy, Howard Mason & Pat Hayes - ConferenceCall_2009_06_19
- 2009_05_14 - Thursday: OntologySummit2009 postmortem and follow-up planning - Chair: Steve Ray - ConferenceCall_2009_05_14
- Our OntologySummit2009_Communique has been adopted and released ... A huge THANK YOU to everyone who helped put this important document together!
- We had two very productive days at the OntologySummit2009 6~7-Apr-2009 Face-to-Face Workshop and Symposium ... proceedings of the sessions are now available at: OntologySummit2009_Symposium
- Key pre-Summit Workshop Events:
- 2009_03_12 - Thursday: OntologySummit2009 Panel Discussion - "Ontology Community Perspectives Toward Ontology-based Standards" - Chair: Michael Grüninger - Panelists: Barry Smith, Edward Barkmeyer, BillMcCarthy and Conrad Bock - ConferenceCall_2009_03_12
- 2009_03_19 - Thursday: OntologySummit2009 Panel Discussion - "Standards Community Perspectives Toward Ontology-based Standards" - Chair: Howard Mason - Panelists: Matthew West, David Leal, Gerald Radack, Nicolas Figay, David Shorter and David Price - ConferenceCall_2009_03_19
- 2009_03_26 - Thursday: OntologySummit2009 Panel Discussion - "Toward Ontology-based Standards - A Synthesis" - Chair: Steve Ray - Panelists: Howard Mason, Michael Grüninger, David Connelly, Katherine Goodier, David Leal, Nicolas Figay - ConferenceCall_2009_03_26
- Key Content Pages:
- 2009_01_15 - Thursday: OntologySummit2009 Launch Event - ConferenceCall_2009_01_15
- 2008_12_18 - Thursday: OntologySummit2009: "Ontologies as the Next Generation of Information Standards" - Communitywide brainstorming and planning session for our next ontology summit in Spring 2009 - ConferenceCall_2008_12_18
- we are soliciting ideas for this next summit, comprising 3 months of virtual discourse and events, which will culminate into a communique and a 2-day face-to-face workshop - please post your thoughts to the OntologySummit2009/Idea page or to the [ ontology-summit ] mailing list ... (=ppy/2008.12.16)
- The following dates are already locked-in (please mark your calendars):
- 2009_04_06~07 - Monday & Tuesday: OntologySummit2009_Symposium (face-to-face workshop) at NIST (Gaithersburg, Maryland, USA)
Objective
Theme: "Toward Ontology-based Standards"
Description, Goals & Objectives
This summit will address the intersection of two active communities, namely the technical standards world, and the community of ontology and semantic technologies. This intersection is long overdue because each has much to offer the other. Ontologies represent the best efforts of the technical community to unambiguously capture the definitions and interrelationships of concepts in a variety of domains. Standards - specifically information standards - are intended to provide unambiguous specifications of information, for the purpose of error-free access and exchange. If the standards community is indeed serious about specifying such information unambiguously to the best of its ability, then the use of ontologies as the vehicle for such specifications is the logical choice.
Conversely, the standards world can provide a large market for the industrial use of ontologies, since ontologies are explicitly focused on the precise representation of information. This will be a boost to worldwide recognition of the utility and power of ontological models.
The goal of this Ontology Summit 2009 is to articulate the power of synergizing these two communities in the form of a communique in which a number of concrete challenges can be laid out. These challenges could serve as a roadmap that will galvanize both communities and bring this promising technical area to the attention of others. Exactly what challenges are chosen is the subject to be debated and decided upon during the electronic discussion period leading up to the face-to-face meeting in April of 2009.
Process & Deliverables
Similar to our last 3 summits, this Ontology Summit will comprise of 3 months of virtual discourse (over our archived mailing lists) and virtual panel sessions (over augmented conference calls), and will culminate in a 2-day face-to-face workshop/symposium to be held in the Spring of 2009 at NIST (Gaithersburg, Maryland, US) during which we will, among other things, distill our thoughts into a collaboratively developed Communiqué (and possibly even a range of follow-up projects and action items.)
The Team
- Organizing Committee:
- Alan Ruttenberg
- Anders Tell
- Barry Smith
- BillMcCarthy
- David Connelly
- David Leal
- David Price
- Elisa Kendall
- Evan Wallace
- Fabian Neuhaus
- Frank Olken
- Henson Graves
- Howard Mason
- Katherine Goodier
- Kurt Conrad
- Laurent Liscia
- Leo Obrst
- Mark Carlisle
- Mark Musen
- Matthew West
- Michael Grüninger
- Mike Dean
- Nicola Guarino
- Nils Sandsmark
- Pat Hayes
- Peter Benson
- Peter Brown
- Peter P. Yim
- Rex Brooks
- Rudi Studer
- Simon Frechette
- Stefan Decker
- Steve Ray (General Chair)
- Trish Whetzel
- Advisory Committee:
- Alan Ruttenberg
- Aldo Gangemi
- Asuman Dogac
- Barry Smith
- BillMcCarthy
- Conrad Bock
- Chris Chute
- Chris Menzel
- Chris Welty
- David Connelly
- David Leal
- David Price
- Denise Bedford
- Doug Lenat
- Duane Nickull
- Elisa Kendall
- Enrico Motta
- Evan Wallace
- Fabian Neuhaus
- Henson Graves
- Howard Mason
- Ian Horrocks
- Ivan Herman
- JamieClark
- John Bateman
- John F. Sowa
- Katherine Goodier
- Ken Baclawski
- Kurt Conrad
- Laurent Liscia
- Leo Obrst
- Marcia Zeng
- Mark Greaves
- Mark Musen
- Martin Hepp
- Matthew West
- Michael Grüninger
- Michel Bohms
- Michelle Raymond
- Mike Dean
- Mitsuhiro Okada
- Nicola Guarino
- Nigel Shaw
- Nils Sandsmark
- Olivier Bodenreider
- Pat Hayes
- Paul Buitelaar
- Peter Benson
- Peter Brown
- Peter Haase
- Peter P. Yim
- Rex Brooks
- RichardMarkSoley
- Rick Murphy
- Rob Raskin
- Rudi Studer
- Simon Frechette
- Stefan Decker
- Stefano Bertolo
- Steve Ray (General Chair)
- Tim Finin
- TimMcGrath
- Co-Sponsors: ('Co-sponsors' are organizations who are providing technical or funding support, and/or endorsing the purpose (i.e. the objective) of this Ontology Summit)
- The Applied Ontology journal (NicolaGuarino & MarkMusen)
- Accuracy&Aesthetics (DeborahMacPherson)
- BBN (MikeDean)
- Bremen Ontology Research Group at Bremen University, supported by the faculties of Informatics and Linguistics and the Collaborative Research Center for Spatial Cognition (JohnBateman / TillMossakowski)
- Department of Philosophy, University at Buffalo (BarrySmith)
- CAESAR Systems Limited (DavidLeal)
- CIM3 (PeterYim)
- CNR Institute for Cognitive Sciences and Technologies, Laboratory of Applied Ontology (Trento & Rome) (NicolaGuarino & AldoGangemi)
- Cycorp (DougLenat)
- DERI - Digital Enterprise Research Institute (StefanDecker)
- ECCMA - Electronic Commerce Code Management Association (PeterBenson)
- EDM Council - Enterprise Data Management Council (MikeBennett)
- EIS - EIS Encyclopedic Systems Ltd (EU) & Entsiklopedicheskiye Intellektualniye Systemy (RU) (AzamatAbdoullaev)
- EPISTLE - European Process Industries STEP Technical Liaison Executive, the consortium responsible for the development of ISO 15926 (MatthewWest)
- Eurostep (NigelShaw, DavidPrice)
- IBM Research (ChrisWelty)
- Institute for Human and Machine Cognition (IHMC) (PatHayes)
- Information Junction (MatthewWest)
- RexBrooks
- ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 32 N 1498 - ISO 24707 Common Logic (CL) Working Group (HarryDelugach (editor), Pat Hayes, Chris Menzel, John F. Sowa, MurrayAltheim, Elisa Kendall, et al.)
- ISO TC 184/SC4 (HowardMason, David Price, DavidLeal)
- ISO TC 184 SC 4 JWG8 - the ISO working group that developed the ISO 18629 Process Specification Language (PSL) standard (MichaelGruninger)
- The Department of Accounting and Information Systems, Michigan State University (BillMcCarthy)
- MITRE (LeoObrst, PatCassidy)
- NCBO - The National Center for Biomedical Ontology (MarkMusen)
- NCOR - (US) National Center for Ontological Research (BarrySmith & MarkMusen)
- The NeOn project (EnricoMotta, Aldo Gangemi, PeterHaase)
- NIST - (US) National Institute of Standards and Technology (SteveRay, Simon Frechette, Mark Carlisle, Evan Wallace, FabianNeuhaus)
- NLM, NIH - (US) National Library of Medicine of the National Institute of Health (OlivierBodenreider)
- The College of Computer and Information Science, Northeastern University (LarryFinkelstein, KenBaclawski)
- OAGi - Open Applications Group (DavidConnelly)
- OASIS - Organization for the Advancement of Structured Information Standards (LaurentLiscia, Peter Brown, JamieClark, et al.)
- OASIS Semantic Support for Electronic Business Document Interoperability (SET) Technical Committee (AsumanDogac)
- OASIS Universal Business Language (UBL) Technical Committee (JonBosak & TimMcGrath)
- OMG - Object Management Group (RichardMarkSoley, Elisa Kendall, EvanWallace)
- Ontolog (PeterYim, Leo Obrst, KurtConrad)
- Pensive.eu (PeterBrown)
- POSC Caesar (NilsSandsmark)
- The Stanford Center for Biomedical Informatics Research (BMIR) (MarkMusen, TrishWhetzel)
- STI International (RudiStuder)
- Department of Philosophy, Texas A&M University (ChrisMenzel)
- University of Toronto (MichaelGruninger)
- W3C - World Wide Web Consortium (IvanHerman & Ian Jacobs)
- Conveners:
- these are key participants who provided substantive contribution to the OntologySummit2009 initiative through:
- the online discourse,
- the research and subsequent synthesis work,
- authoring/presentation of various relevant positions and perspectives (for this Summit),
- preparing the drafts of relevant documentation and our Summit "Communique" (which were then collaboratively reviewed and adopted during the face-to-face meetings),
- participants at the face-to-face meetings (either on-site or remotely), and
- all members of the organizing committee
- to these conveners, who made this initiative a reality, we express our deepest appreciation and gratitude.
- these are key participants who provided substantive contribution to the OntologySummit2009 initiative through:
You are cordially invited to join us!
- Like all activities Ontolog has been hosting, this is open to everyone.
- Do join us if you concur with the theme and objective of this endeavor and would like to participate in, or follow the progress of the discourse
- specific individuals who may be interested include (but not limit to):
- members of ontology communities
- members of standards development communities
- ontology, taxonomy and terminology repository/repository technology developers
- upper and domain ontology researchers and developers
- ontology-based application developers and implementors
- active players in the ontology community
- potential user organizations
- potential funders of ontology and ontological engineering work
- representatives from International Standards Bodies
- thought leaders and active contributors of the semantic technology community
- leaders of the semantic web community
- people in academia, research, industry and the web working on sharing knowledge, semantic interoperability, knowledge representation, artificial intelligence ... who are engaged in the research, development, engineering and implementation of these subject matters
- ...
- Collection of Resources and Community Contribution Summary workspace on this wiki:
Conference Call, Meeting & Workshop
Open / Convener Sessions
- 2009_10_08 - Thursday: Progress Review on the OntologyBasedStandards sample projects identified at OntologySummit2009 - Chair: Steve Ray - Panelists: David Connelly, Matthew West, Mike Bennett, Brand Niemann, Kevin Keck, David Coggeshall, Joshua Lieberman, Ed Barkmeyer - ConferenceCall_2009_10_08
- 2009_05_14 - Thursday: OntologySummit2009 postmortem and follow-up planning - Chair: Steve Ray - ConferenceCall_2009_05_14
- OntologySummit2009 (F2F) Symposium - 2009_04_06~07 - Monday & Tuesday: OntologySummit2009_Symposium (face-to-face workshop) at NIST (Gaithersburg, Maryland, USA)
- 2009_03_26 - Thursday: OntologySummit2009 Panel Discussion - "Toward Ontology-based Standards - A Synthesis" - Chair: Steve Ray - Panelists: Howard Mason, Michael Grüninger, David Connelly, Katherine Goodier, David Leal, Nicolas Figay - ConferenceCall_2009_03_26
- 2009_03_19 - Thursday: OntologySummit2009 Panel Discussion - "Standards Community Perspectives Toward Ontology-based Standards" - Chair: Howard Mason - Panelists: Matthew West, David Leal, Gerald Radack, Nicolas Figay, David Shorter and David Price - ConferenceCall_2009_03_19
- 2009_03_12 - Thursday: OntologySummit2009 Panel Discussion - "Ontology Community Perspectives Toward Ontology-based Standards" - Chair: Michael Grüninger - Panelists: Barry Smith, Edward Barkmeyer, BillMcCarthy and Conrad Bock - ConferenceCall_2009_03_12
- 2009_01_15 - Thursday: OntologySummit2009 Launch Event - ConferenceCall_2009_01_15
- Pre-launch planning meeting - 2008_12_18 - Thursday: OntologySummit2009: "Ontologies as the Next Generation of Information Standards" - Communitywide brainstorming and planning session for our next ontology summit in Spring 2009 - ConferenceCall_2008_12_18
Organizing Committee Sessions
- Thu 2009.02.26 - Third OntologySummit2009 Organizing Committee conference call - OntologySummit2009/OrganizingCommitteeMeeting_2009_02_26
- Thu 2009.01.15 - Second OntologySummit2009 Organizing Committee conference call - OntologySummit2009/OrganizingCommitteeMeeting_2009_01_15
- Thu 2008.12.18 - First OntologySummit2009 Organizing Committee conference call - OntologySummit2009/OrganizingCommitteeMeeting_2008_12_18
Ontology Summit 2009 in the News, Blogosphere & Literature
- FWIW, some shorter urls (to the Summit Communique) for tweeting, facebook, identi.ca, etc. ... from Ed Dodds / 2009.04.10
- http://tinyurl.com/OntologySummit2009-Communique
- http://bit.ly/OntologySummit2009_Communique
- http://is.gd/rOt5
- Twitter hash tag #ontologforum
- Mike's Digital Laboratory post - MikeAxelrod / 2009.04.09
- "Data reuse not possible without ontological work, group asserts" - Joab Jackson - GCN / 2009.04.07
- UMBC ebiguity post - TimFinin / 2009.03.15
- posts on the OASIS Cover Page: (1), (2) - Robin Cover / 2009.03.04 & 2009.04.13
- Conmergence Post - EdDodds / 2009.01.13
- #OntologySummit2009 tag created for Twitter Tweets
Additional Resources
- Homepage of Ontology Summit 2008
- Homepage of Ontology Summit 2007
- Homepage of UpperOntologySummit (2006)
This page is maintained by members of the OntologySummit2009 Organizing Committee.