Actions

Ontolog Forum

Revision as of 02:19, 26 April 2013 by imported>PeterYim (PeterYim moved page ZTool-123 to Z Tool-123)
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)

Return to the survey

General

Full name of the tool Tool-123
Description of the tool This is just an example. I will use references to OOR to complete this sample.
Link to the tool http://oor.net
Tool home page http://ontolog.cim3.net/cgi-bin/wiki.pl?OpenOntologyRepository
Download page http://sandbox.oor.net
Author OOR team
Contact Peter Yim <peter.yim@cim3.com>
Institutional sponsor OOR Initiative
Last version sandbox
License code: BSD; content: CC-BY-3.0
Mailing List [[Mailing List::[oor-forum], [oor-users], [oor-dev] - see: http://ontolog.cim3.net/cgi-bin/wiki.pl?OpenOntologyRepository#nid17YY]]

Exploration

Find ontologies with specific domain coverage Yes
-- comment a search (for ontology names; classes; etc.) is available
Compare domain coverage across ontologies Yes
-- comment Optional remarks
Assess or characterize breadth of domain coverage of an ontology Yes
-- comment Optional remarks
Assess or characterize depth or detail of domain coverage of an ontology No
-- comment Optional remarks
Assess or characterize use considerations of ontology including licensing, training, cost, updating, software requirements, and security No
-- comment Optional remarks
Assess complexity of concept definitions (necessary and sufficient properties) and use of axioms No
-- comment Optional remarks
Identify number and ratio of concepts, relations, and subclassing No
-- comment Optional remarks
Identify frequency of use of ontology language features in an ontology No
-- comment Optional remarks
Identify age and use statistics of an ontology and its versions No
-- comment Optional remarks
Assess the inferencing power of an ontology No
-- comment Optional remarks
Rate ontologies on their popularity or review feedback No
-- comment Optional remarks
Other ontology quality and fitness support for exploration phase (describe capability) testing ... 1 2 3

Management

Distinguish between conceptual and operational ontologies and objectives No
-- comment Optional remarks
Generate ontology application and performance requirements No
-- comment Optional remarks
Organize and track the life cycle requirements and progression of an ontology No
-- comment Optional remarks
Organize and maintain a collection of related ontologies and ontology modules No
-- comment Optional remarks
Provide statistics on ontology versioning and use No
-- comment Optional remarks
Guide ontology development per a quality assurance methodology No
-- comment Optional remarks
Assess the reusability of a planned ontology No
-- comment Optional remarks
Other ontology quality and fitness support for management phase (describe capability)

Design

Does Z Tool-123 guide formulation of ontology requirements?
Guide formulation of domain scope and detail requirements No
-- comment Optional remarks
Guide formulation of goodness of design requirements No
-- comment Optional remarks
Guide formulation of data and information requirements No
-- comment Optional remarks
Guide formulation of semantic and reasoning requirements No
-- comment Optional remarks
Guide formulation of interface requirements No
-- comment Optional remarks
Guide formulation of level of effort requirements No
-- comment Optional remarks
Facilitate framing a set of competency questions exemplifying ontology objectives No
-- comment Optional remarks
Choose metaphysical methodology No
-- comment Optional remarks
Does Z Tool-123 allow one to choose an extant ontology for reuse?
Choose extant top ontology for reuse No
-- comment Optional remarks
Choose extant core ontologies for reuse No
-- comment Optional remarks
Apply a style of ontological analysis to design No
-- comment Optional remarks
Guide design to optimize normalization, factoring, and simplicity of ontology No
-- comment Optional remarks
Guide application of open world or closed world semantics No
-- comment Optional remarks
Guide ontology design to achieve inferencing requirements No
-- comment Optional remarks
Guide ontology design to achieve scalability requirements No
-- comment Optional remarks
Enable adjustable query and inference performance No
-- comment Optional remarks
Does Z Tool-123 offer design patterns based on current ontology or design context?
Offer application patterns based on current ontology or design context No
-- comment Optional remarks
Offer ontology language patterns based on current ontology or design context No
-- comment Optional remarks
Offer methodology patterns based on current ontology or design context No
-- comment Optional remarks
Offer other patterns based on current ontology or design context No
-- comment Optional remarks
Integrate selected design patterns into an ontology design No
-- comment Optional remarks
Assess correctness or performance of an ontology design No
-- comment Optional remarks
Guide and facilitate modularization of ontology No
-- comment Optional remarks
Guide ontology design for visualization No
-- comment Optional remarks
Other ontology quality and fitness support for design phase (describe capability)

Build

General Development

Does Z Tool-123 allow one to choose an ontology language?
Choose ontology language No
-- comment Optional remarks
Choose formal logic language No
-- comment Optional remarks
Choose RDF support No
-- comment Optional remarks
Mix ontology languages No
-- comment Optional remarks
Generate ontology code from requirements specification No
-- comment Optional remarks
Generate or enforce selected design patterns in ontology code No
-- comment Optional remarks
Feedback on consistency of granularity and regularity of domain ontology structure No
-- comment Optional remarks
Manage lexical naming and annotation of ontology elements No
-- comment Optional remarks
Ensure proper use and coding of RDF and Web resources No
-- comment Optional remarks
Enforce proper use and coding of URIs No
-- comment Optional remarks
Produce the current terminological inferences of an ontology No
-- comment Optional remarks
Optimize query and inference performance No
-- comment Optional remarks
Detect violations of domain, referential, or semantic integrity No
-- comment Optional remarks
Overall, detect and correct coding errors or inconsistencies No
-- comment Optional remarks
Other ontology quality and fitness support for build phase (describe capability)

Concept Development

Ensure proper separation and coding of concepts and facts No
-- comment Optional remarks
Ensure kind-of nature and consistency of subclassing No
-- comment Optional remarks
Guide subclass versus class individual determinations No
-- comment Optional remarks
Monitor depth of subclassing consistency across a domain ontology No
-- comment Optional remarks
Generate prototypical instances (individuals) to help verify class intent and class subsumption No
-- comment Optional remarks
Detect and guide use of multiple inheritance No
-- comment Optional remarks
Guide use of disjointness axioms No
-- comment Optional remarks
Guide use of necessary and sufficient properties in concept definitions No
-- comment Optional remarks
Guide use of existential versus universal quantification in class restrictions No
-- comment Optional remarks
Enforce proper use of conjunctions versus disjunctions No
-- comment Optional remarks

Relationship Development

Ensure proper use and coding of relations No
-- comment Optional remarks
Ensure proper use and coding of data types No
-- comment Optional remarks
Assess and enforce consistency and completeness of range and domain constraints No
-- comment Optional remarks
Assess and enforce consistency and completeness of inverse relations No
-- comment Optional remarks
Ensure proper use and coding of transitive relations No
-- comment Optional remarks

Validation

Verify that ontology requirements are met No
-- comment Optional remarks
Can Z Tool-123 assess query performance?
Assess query precision and recall performance No
-- comment Optional remarks
Assess query time performance No
-- comment Optional remarks
Can Z Tool-123 assess inference performance?
Assess inferencing time performance No
-- comment Optional remarks
Assess inferencing completeness performance No
-- comment Optional remarks
Generate characteristic queries and tests No
-- comment Optional remarks
Accept validation test sets or inputs No
-- comment Optional remarks
Can Z Tool-123 assure computability of ontology?
Assure semantically adequate computability of ontology No
-- comment Optional remarks
Assure mathematically complete computability of ontology No
-- comment Optional remarks
Verify that two ontologies are interoperable No
-- comment Optional remarks
Validate the intended functionality of software using the ontology No
-- comment Optional remarks
Validate instance data conforming to an ontology No
-- comment Optional remarks
Assess accuracy, correctness, and completeness of ontology terminological content No
-- comment Optional remarks
Guide or adjust ontology in accord with validation results No
-- comment Optional remarks
Other ontology quality and fitness support for validation phase (describe capability)

Integration and Use

Export ontology in different languages No
-- comment Optional remarks
Integrate ontology with other ontologies No
-- comment Optional remarks
Integrate ontology with other information system resources No
-- comment Optional remarks
Assess or track user experience with ontology No
-- comment Optional remarks
Enable user to modify or extend ontology to address deficiencies No
-- comment Optional remarks
Create mappings from ontologies to and from data and data sources No
-- comment Optional remarks
Other ontology quality and fitness support for integration and use phase (describe capability)

Maintenance

Promote reuse of ontology No
-- comment Optional remarks
Capture ontology errors during use No
-- comment Optional remarks
Profile use of ontology elements during use No
-- comment Optional remarks
Compare and map between ontologies No
-- comment Optional remarks
Track ontology changes and control versions Yes
-- comment Testing
Other ontology quality and fitness support for maintenance phase (describe capability) TESTING ... please ignore